CSI Atlas

How Atlas decides

The written rule set that decides what becomes public, what is held and what is archived. No person approves an individual finding.

Published findings: 195

Held by policy: 439

Awaiting a publication decision: 0

Policy version

This page describes policy automated-review-v2, reviewed 15 Nov 2026. The rule set is public so a reader can check the reason for any published finding and any absence.

Automated decisions carry the public label Automated source check. This publication does not claim that a person reviewed an automated record, and it does not claim that a check proves a claim is true.

The three outcomes

Every record receives exactly one outcome.
OutcomeWhat it meansWhat it is not
PublishAccepted and public. An allowed claim class from a tier 1 official source, or a tier 2 vetted research publisher as attributed research. The cited original must be retrieved and support the wording, and the date must be inside the window.The public label is Automated source check. No person reviewed it.
HoldNot published and not public. A sensitive class, a secondary source, a failed gate or a claim type the allowlist does not cover.Re-decided when the policy version changes.
ArchiveRemoved from the review state with a recorded reason. The capture is kept.Reference catalogues, media carriers, duplicates and out-of-scope items.

Source tiers

A tier is a role and rights decision about the publisher. It is not a truth score. A source may be trusted to report something; it is never trusted to make this publication conclusion for it.

Registered publishers by tier.
TierWhat the publisher isHow it may be usedRegistered sources
1Official or primary recordOfficial or primary9
2Vetted research or vendor analysisVetted research or vendor6
3Vetted news reportingVetted media3
4Reference catalogue or social sourceReference or social10

Checks, in order

The checks run before any judgment about content. A failed check ends the decision; the record cannot be published by a later step. Every decision stores each check, the evidence span it compared, the reason and the time.

Deterministic checks and their failure outcome.
CheckWhat it comparesWhen it fails
Source identityThe publisher is in the trust register, is active, and its tier and claim mode are recorded.No decision that could publish
Domain bindingThe cited source host matches the registered publisher domain.Hold
Current source bytesA recent check succeeded and the retained bytes still match their recorded digest.Hold
Item hashThe captured item, as digested, is the item the record cites.Hold
Exact wordingThe record title is the wording the source item carried, not a rewrite.Hold
QuotationA quotation renders only when the terms allow it and the wording is found in retained text.Quotation removed, gap stated
Date roleThe publication date is explicit and inside the publication window.Hold
TermsThe recorded reuse terms allow this mode of publication.Hold
Duplicate clusterAnother record does not already carry the same item.Archive
Personal data classThe captured text carries no personal contact, special category or criminal offence marker.Hold
Claim classThe claim is one the allowlist permits this version to publish.Hold

What may publish without a person

A tier 1 official report, or a tier 2 attributed research item whose original document was retrieved and checked, in one of these claim classes: vulnerabilities, malware, infrastructure, supply_chain. Every other claim class is held, including legal proceedings, financial flows, entity and person attribution, breach exposure and incidents.

A tier 2 item is attributed research. It states what the named publisher reports, not an Atlas conclusion, and it never carries an ownership or guilt claim.

The published wording is the source report. The record keeps the source link, its date, the claim type and its uncertainty. This publication adds no conclusion about guilt, ownership, motive or amount.

What never publishes automatically

The learning stage

The learning stage is disabled in this version. Source text is not sent to any provider. A disabled stage is recorded as disabled, never as a pass.

A model would be used only after the deterministic checks, and only on cleared text. It would produce a structured decision with the evidence spans it compared. It would never widen the allowlist, and a model score would never replace a failed check.

Limits and how to correct us

This is an alpha publication. The rules change and mistakes are expected. A published record can be corrected: the previous wording and the corrected wording are both kept, with the reason and the date, in the corrections log. A record that loses its source or its verification is de-quoted, and the gap is stated on the record.

Report an error or read the correction log. Read the privacy note.

Policy review and recertification dates are recorded in the source register. A source whose registration expires cannot quote or publish.